Nick Mamatas' response to Liz Henry's review was to call her a "teenyboper."
1. I've known Liz since 1987 when we were both undergrads at UT Austin. So he's wrong on a matter of fact.
2. He could had said he didn't find any redeeming features in the novel. Liz found something worthwhile in the novel. He could had disagreed with Liz on the matter of opinion.
3. I haven't read the novel yet, so I can't respond as to the worthiness/non-worthiness other than to trust Liz's opinion because she's hella smart.
4. I think Nick was out of line with the namecalling.