Aug. 9th, 2006
- 8:06 AM
Middles. Otherwise known as The Hard Part.
Well, unless, for you, beginnings or endings are the hard part. For me, it's middles. (A work of fiction is composed of three parts--a beginning, an ending, and a muddle. And so forth.)
This is where the fine art of recomplication comes in. If the opening of a novel is devoted to setting up the situation, demonstrating the conflict, introducing the characters and the world, the middle is about building and maintaining stakes. (and getting to the climax, of course.)
I like to say that I just keep breaking things until I can't figure a way out, which is pretty accurate. But there's a balance to it--the narrative has to reward (pay off) as it recomplicates, or it becomes boring. In other words, you can't stretch one question for 500 pages. Well, okay, you can. But along the way there need to be mini-arcs, small conflicts and small resolutions, little victories to go with the losses. Otherwise, the book becomes, well, one-note. And can be enjoyed as well by skipping to the end as by reading the entire narrative.
That's all very vague and not very practical, isn't it?
Okay, here. So you've gotten to the end of the setup, you've hit the point where you're not sure what happens next, and you're stuck at the previously discussed Inevitable 30K (35K, 40K) Wall. You are staring the Dreaded Middle Of The Book in the eye, and it's not looking down.
What do you do?
This is the time for the first major reversal. Give the characters something. Take something else away.
Jean Valjean agrees to rescue Fantine's daughter, but he's also confronted with his Wicked Past. Conflicting obligations! And a cop is on his trail! Raise the stakes!
Send in that man with the gun. Kill somebody. Get somebody laid. Hand him the key to the puzzle and then snatch it away. Change it up!
Open three books you like to page 150 and see what's going on. Flip a few dozen pages to either side. I betcha, in most of them, something Big will have just changed.
And then you follow the implications of that reversal to the next reversal, and so on, until everything goes boom.
BOOM!
like that.
***
- Mood:
helpful

Profile
matociquala- it's a great life, if you don't weaken
- Elizabeth Bear Dot Com
Links
- Shadow Unit
- My official website, with all the official stuff on it.
- Tor.com
- Wikipedia current events
- Storytellersunplugged.com
- Locus Online
- FICTONS: Elizabeth Bear's Fiction Journal
- Swag!
- "Join Me Or Die!" (essay)
- Analog Science Fiction and Fact
- Asimov's Science Fiction
- Ralan
- The Black Hole
- Jennifer Jackson
- Online Writing Workshops
- On Spec
- Ideomancer
- Chiaroscuro Magazine
- Subterranean Magazine
Tags
- !!!eleventy-one!!!
- (new) england
- *really* shameless self promotion
- --30--
- 0.o
- 100 book reports
- 100 words for snow
- 1796
- 2005 in review
- 2008 bookkeeping
- 2009 bookkeeping
- 2009 worldcon
- 4th street
- 52 book challenge
- 70's brit sf
- 7fas
- 9 things about oracles
- a bear in her natural habitat
- a companion to wolves
- a modest proposal
- a moment of silence
- a policeman's work is never done
- abby irene
- abigail irene
- aby irene
- actw
- administrivia
- adult survivor
- adventures in dining
- advice from people who know more
- ain't that just like life?
- alcohol abuse
- all about the goddamn verbs
- all knowledge is contained in lj
- all the windwracked stars
- all three sides of the story
- all together too much: jethro tull
- almost but not entirely unlike tea
- always got room for a goon
- americana
- amusement value
- an armada of glass cats
- and so the ranch was saved
- angst
- animation
- another time-wasting music post
- another tom to clog our narrative
- any work but the work we must
- applied selfishness
- are we still cops?
- armistice day
- arom
- arrant pedantry
- art
- arthuriana
- ask a stupid question
- ass from a hole in the ground
- at home with autodidacticism
- attachment is the root of suffering
- atws
- auctorial fetishes
- audio sweet audio
- autumn in new england
- awards
- b&@k hate
- baa baa black sheep
- baa baa black sheep... er bunny
- barney flies the hovercraft
- bavarian babushkas
- bear appearances
- bear necessities
- bearmalion
- bears translation
- because i'm a one-armed quebecois ex-con
- because it is there
- beer
- ben
- best roomie ever
- big blue boyscout
- bill & kit's bogus journey
- billion-$ satellites to find tupperware
- biology
- bittercon
- blank page and a bloody forehead
- blood & iron
- blood and rhetoric
- blood rhetoric & love
- bloodsucking freaks
- bloody americans
- bone & jewel creatures
- boojum
- book 'em dano
- book covers
- book recs
- book reports
- bookkeeping
- bookkeeping 2009
- books
- boom
- boosting signal
- bork! bork! bork!
- boskone 43
- boston
- bpal
- braiiiiiiiiiiiiiiins!
- brain squirrels
- bring back the boston rag
- brits attempting southern accents
- broken because you're brittle
- btmb
- burning sappho loved and sung
- but everybody loves werewolves!
- but that trick never works
- butterflies will eat me
- can't sleep clowns will eat me
- carnival
- carpet-bombing with the f-word
- cat pictures
- catwaxing
- chairdancing
- chandlery
- chapbook
- charles stross
- charting waters of caffeine addiction
- chatroom transcripts
- childhood trauma
- chill
- clarion west
- clarion west 2009
- classical references
- close the wall up with our english dead
- club scene
- clustermap
- cognitive dissonance
- collective action
- come be the big fat lady
- comics
- community
- completely pointless polls
- concerts
- contest
- conventioneering
- cooking
- cover art
- crankiness
- crass materialism
- criticism
- critique
- cryptozoology
- cultural necropsy
- cultural phenomena
- cupcakecon 2009
- current events
- cute pet stories
- cv
- dance like a spaz
- darwin was right
- dating myself
- death by pollen
- death-mosey
- deathmarch
- deathmarch 2007!
- deathmarch 2008
- deathmarch 2008!
- deathmarch 2009
- deathmarch 2009!
- deathrace 2007!
- decadence
- decompensating
- deconstructing folk songs
- delivered wisdom
- did i get any on you?
- disco vampires
- displacement activity
- do doodily do
- doctor who
- doggerel
- dogs and cats living together
- dogs aren't dangerous!
- don't let ur babies grow up to be gamers
- don't put your finger there
- dorothy parker
- down the rabbit hole
- dragoncave
- dragonsbane
- drama reviews
- dreams
- dreams and bones
- drop and give me twenty
- dust
- east african plains ape
- eat a live frog and--
- eat anything bigger than your head
- eco-gothic
- edda of burdens
- eek a bug
- eek!
- egoboo
- einstein and me
- either your rings or greenmantle or else
- elaine andraste
- elizabethan penis jokes
- empty your foot
- english motherfucker do you read it?
- entropy always wins
- entropy requires no maintenance
- eric stoltz
- eslc
- espionage
- etc.
- eulogies
- eureka
- everybody talks about the weather
- everything's better with ninja
- evil crochet
- evil sexy leonard cohen
- exposition
- face down in the cheerios again
- facepalm
- fail better
- falling off perfectly good rocks
- falling off perfectly good rocks.
- falling off perfectly good walls
- fan service
- fandom
- fanfiction
- fauna
- fearless kitten
- fearless kjitten
- felicity
- feminism
- fiction recs
- fictional geographies
- fine art
- finger-pricking in five-four-three
- finnish pop: still weird
- first lines meme
- five minute's walk if it's not raining
- five random things
- five things
- fizzicks
- fnu with tyops
- foggy cities viewed from a height
- food porn
- food snuff porn
- footnotes to history
- forensic cookery
- forensic ukrainian cookery
- fountain pen neep
- free online fiction
- freight elevator to hell
- friends don't let friends play banjo
- froth
- fscking "authorship" question
- full-formed from the head of seuss
- future shock
- fuzzy companion animal fantasy
- galley goggles
- gastronomique a la white trash
- gastrotourism
- geeks make the best rock stars
- geeks on parade
- geeks with guns
- genderfuck
- genre
- get out in park
- get out in the park
- getting crowley's goat
- giant ridiculous dog
- giant ridiculous dogge
- gifties
- gip
- girl cooties
- girl percival
- give us this day our daily grind
- glam or not glam
- glee on behalf of another
- gleek! stick your nose in!
- go read this
- gobsmacked
- god hates shrimp
- goth bowling
- gotham
- gothercise
- gothercize
- grail
- grammar police!
- gratitude
- gratuitous baby picspam
- grave robbery on the high seas
- gravity always wins
- greg rucka
- grow your own
- grump grump grump
- guitar god in training
- gunfight on fremont street
- ha ha only serious
- hacking reality
- hacking the meatpuppet
- hair today gone tomorrow
- hairspray and pastel
- half a dead vole
- hammered
- hand porn
- hardcore arms race
- harebrained schemes
- hark the herald tribune sings
- harrison bergeron eat your heart out
- he's the goddamn batman
- heavy weather
- help me internets you're my only hope
- hemoise sez
- here: breath into this paper bag bear
- heroic hookers
- hesitation wounds
- hey rocky!
- hi mom!
- hic!
- history: not just for breakfast
- hitting makes me feel better
- hobgoblin consistency
- hobnoblin blues
- hog-slopping
- home psychoanalysis at home
- honeydew
- horticulture (no really: horticulture)
- hot wax and hair dye
- how high can you go?
- how sausage gets made
- hoyay
- huge tracts of... land
- human rights
- humor
- i got yer jetpack right here
- i have a fandom?!
- i need a hobby
- i spy
- i will not start a flamewar
- i'm not proud (or tired)
- icons
- ideomancer
- if all your friends jumped off a sheep
- if it were easy it wouldn't be fun
- in lieu of content
- in the end i used a hammer
- in which bear gushes about bad tv
- in which bear is bearlike again
- industry
- inexplicable weirdness
- inking process
- intercultural disconnect
- internet bedtime stories
- internet slapfights
- internet timewasters
- interviews
- it came from the blogosphere
- it came from the trunk
- it sounds like you had an epiphany
- it's not about you
- it's turtles turtles turtles
- jackie
- jay-mocking
- jenny
- jenny casey
- john henry holliday
- john hiatt - god's golden eye
- john joseph adams
- john ronald reuel
- joined in progress
- journey to the fryolator
- just a girl
- just wow
- justify your existence
- katrina
- ken on the bible
- kgb
- kidding--i'm kidding--kidding!
- killer robots
- kirsten vangsness
- kit
- kitchen wildlife
- la
- language
- learned helplessness
- lefthand monkeywrench of the patriarchy
- leverage
- life imitates us
- life imitating
- life is a highway
- life is an adventure
- life is short and art is long
- line of direction
- link salad
- lit pimp
- literary wank
- litrachur
- live without a net
- lives of unparalleled glamour
- living in the future
- living jewelry
- lj maintenance
- local scene
- loose tea for loose women
- lost in translation
- madder than a wet paper wasp
- maine
- maintenance
- malodorous catass
- manchester england england
- maneating pony
- manhattan
- market news
- marketing
- materialistic urges
- math is for girls
- matthew the raven
- meat
- media
- meme
- meme warfare
- mental floss
- metatropolis
- method writing
- metrics
- mfu
- michael cisco rocks
- minor medical miracles
- money flows towards the writer
- mongolrocco
- monkey you are funny
- monster field identification
- more-byronesque-than-thou
- morgan freeman in the bathtub
- mother pusbucket
- movies
- multiculturalism in sff
- murphy
- muse-baiting
- music
- music (charitably speaking)
- music maybe
- music recs
- musicals
- my characters plot my downfall
- my country is the whole world
- my despised genre
- my fandom & i'll geek if i want
- my mother drunk or sober
- nadruwrini
- narcissism
- narrative analysis
- naveen
- navel gazing
- navel-gazing
- neither shall they spin
- neurology
- new amsterdam
- new hampshire
- new media
- news
- next time bring a kayak
- night shade
- no girlz allowd
- no mariners did behold
- no really i love harvey!
- no sense of humor of which we are aware
- no shit there i was
- no spambots!!!!
- no such thing as global warming
- nonfiction
- not a podcast
- not enough beer in the world
- not food porn
- not necessarily in that order
- not ten things
- not the kind you have to wind up
- not-a-podcast
- not-so-shameless self-promotion
- note to character
- note to writing partner
- noted without comment
- novel in 90
- now *there's* a demographic
- obituaries
- observed without comment
- oh! chairman mao!
- omg stoppit
- omg we're all gonna die
- omit needless words
- on fire when i lay down
- on the road again
- on this little froggy head
- one horse can run faster than another
- one trick is all that pony knows
- online toys
- oops
- open thread
- organic chemistry
- our despised genre
- overbooked again
- overheard in boston
- painted ponies
- paleogoth
- pathetic fangirl squee
- pathetic self-promotion
- patience & fortitude
- pause for station identification
- pay for the bloody fish
- peace dude
- pedantry
- penguicon
- penny a point ain't no one keeping score
- peregrinations
- performance
- periastron
- perkygoff moment
- peter beagle
- peter watts
- phew
- photo blog
- photoblog
- phun with photoshop
- physics by way of sports metaphors
- pics
- pixel-stained technopeasant wretch
- podcasts
- poetry
- poetry recs
- pointing at the fences
- pointless bitching
- politics
- polls
- polo!
- poltics
- pop culture
- pop quiz!
- pop song psychology
- post-novel ennui
- posthumous jonson
- practical adult solutions
- presumptuous cat
- process
- profeshunal riter do not try at home
- program schedules
- progress nores
- progress notes
- progress reports
- project less-of-me
- project: kilimanjaro
- prokect less-of-me
- promethean age
- proof that god loves us
- psa
- public appearances
- public safety
- publications
- pudge report
- punk long after punk stopped being cool
- puppies
- purple haze
- puttin the x back in xmas
- putting the x back in xmas
- qotd
- quinnehtukqut
- quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
- quotidiana
- racism 101
- ralph the suit is talking to you
- random
- random fandom
- rants
- rape of john crichton
- rats in bad places
- reading against the text
- received wisdom
- recipes
- recovering pagan
- remember remember
- rengeekery
- replete with degrading sex (tm)
- reviews
- revision wingeing
- ridiculous dog
- righteous men
- rita
- road trips
- russian pop: still weird
- sapphire & steel
- sarah monette
- sartorial excess
- say yes to autocannibalism
- say you want a revolution
- scardown
- science fiction is for girls
- science fiction: still dead
- science neep
- science!
- score one for the humanists
- screeds & manifestos
- screw the gst!
- seacoast of bohemia
- seattle 2009
- secrit project
- self amusement
- self-indulgence
- self-motivation thru public humiliation
- serendipitous kitty update
- serendipity
- sff prodom wank
- shadow unit
- shadow unti
- shallow gawking at hot boys
- shameless promotion of somebody else
- shameless self promotion
- sharing the pain
- sherlockia
- shooting things
- shopping
- short attention span theatre
- short fiction
- show me the monkey
- shrill
- signage: an occasional series
- silliness
- silly holidays
- sincerely l. cohen
- singularity
- sloth and villany
- slumber party 2007
- slush monkey
- slut-hat
- small appliance death theatre
- smile
- smut smut and nothing but
- snark
- snide? me snide?
- snow dragons
- snowpocalypse now
- snurri's sense of snow
- so much more than just a breakfast drink
- so not kidding about the spoilers
- so you want to be a writer
- social experiments
- social life
- solicited advice
- some dead gay white guy
- someone in the internets is full of shit
- someone in the internets is wrong
- soopergenius!
- sordid details following
- spaaaaaace!
- spam
- species noted
- spies
- spoiler thread
- spork
- sprezzatura
- spämmers
- stablemates
- stage magic + spy shows = love
- stagecraft and sodomy
- stand up on it
- stars
- stay classy bear
- steampunk in your living room
- steles of the sky
- still not king
- stompy boots
- stone cold sober
- stormbringer
- street date
- stuff that actually works
- stunt writing
- stupid author tricks
- stupid flash games for catwaxing
- suburban peasantry
- sudden gust of solipsism
- sunil
- support your local hack
- surely god will crown the brave
- sushi
- swag
- sycamore hill
- szczegielniak: pronunciation thereof
- talk back & ask questions
- talk back and ask questions
- tea
- teachable moments
- teahouse fox
- technology
- teh gay
- teh suck
- ten things
- textual errors
- that scalzi guy
- the artistic process
- the brownie is nature's perfect food
- the cake is a lie
- the chains that you refuse
- the club scene
- the con is on
- the daily commute
- the daily grind
- the devil can quote scripture
- the discipline
- the doctor
- the dreaded middle of the book
- the edda of burdens
- the editorial process
- the end of the world as we know it
- the folk process
- the future and me
- the glamour!
- the glamour! (and for once i mean it)
- the great guitar experiment
- the grey wolf
- the homosexual agenda
- the horror
- the horrors of self-discipline
- the internet is full of things
- the lion in winter
- the local scene
- the matter of britain
- the meatpuppet is my bitch
- the meta
- the middleman
- the mole-and-bear show
- the more things change the same
- the mythical after time
- the other other white meat
- the perversity of the subconscious mind
- the plot never survives contact
- the reaming order
- the riter at werk
- the river is wide
- the sound of one faucet dripping
- the stars are right
- the things that make me weak & strange
- the trouble with poets is they talk too
- the truth will make you flee
- the u.s. snail
- the unspeakable horror of the literary l
- the wallpaper goes or i go
- the well-waxed cat
- the white city
- the white queen has no santa hat
- the wreck of the lavinia whateley
- the writer at work
- the writers at work
- the writing koans
- theendoftheworldasweknowit
- then go try to live it
- there will always be assholes
- they killed his ass in the second act
- this is for posterity
- this is for science
- this is my bangstick
- this is your brain on folk music
- this old world will never change
- this space intentionally left blank
- this time for sure
- those heinleinian early moderns
- three chords and grimace musically
- tindalosi make great pets
- tmi
- to hell or connacht!
- toilets of the world
- tools
- tools of the trade
- tor.com
- touch the puppethead
- towards a definition
- toxic cock syndrome
- toys
- trains
- trainwreck fascination
- translocation
- travel is broadening
- trenchant observations
- trolls!
- try this at home
- twenty questions
- twistedness
- uk 2006
- unburdening my shelf
- unclean! unclean!
- undertow
- united mythographers
- unplugged
- unspeakable horror of the literary life
- urban fantasy
- urban legends of nevada
- us and them
- utopian musings
- venn diagrams
- venom cock
- viable paradise
- vicious flying llamas
- vincent millay
- virtual party
- virtupitude
- visualize whirled peas
- viva lost wages
- vogon poetry
- vonnegut
- walk to the end of the cem
- walking to mordor bakson
- wank
- war is hell
- war stories
- warblogging wiscon
- waxed cats
- we endorse this product
- we got both kinds of music here
- we have met the enemy and he is us
- wearing a hole in the floor
- web presence
- webcams
- weird brain
- welcome to my nightmare
- welcome wagon
- wf
- what he said
- what i say is almost true
- what was your first clue?
- whatever my rice crispies tell me
- when i say wank i mean wank dammit
- where do you get your ideas?
- while barney flies the hovercraft...
- whinging
- whiskey & water
- whiskey tango foxtrot over
- who's driving this thing?
- why i suck
- wicked fairies
- wicked fairy apologist
- will
- will & kit's bogus journey
- wings and chains
- wips
- wiscon
- with my manuscript or on it
- with my page proofs or on them
- with my slush or on it
- with your draft or on it
- with your garrett or on it
- wolfses
- words: they're all you have
- worldbuilding
- worldcon 2006
- worms:can of:one each
- writing craft wank
- writing is like everything else
- wtc
- wtf
- wtf. media
- xtreme laziness
- yevgeny yevtushenko
- yoga with boobs
- you can't get there from here
- you can't make this up
- you must first understand recursion
- you're in the army now
- your collar
- your freudian slip is showing
Page Summary
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Lizzy Enger
Comments
Psychologically, the first 10-15K words seem hardest to me, because it's not long enough to feel like a book yet. Craft wise, I'm completely with you on the muddle.
Which doesn't seem to happen with short fiction, not even novellas. Is the muddle the distinguishing feature?
Where the idea is basically sound, I can push on through that wall, but I do find Middles difficult. Especially when I look at my notes and see, "Lots of interesting and funny stuff happens."
memorized? memorialized? memoried? whatevermarked out for future reference, as it's the Yawning Chasm of Middles that tend to swallow my stories down.-- Steve's gotta get back on that wagon someday. (Maybe today?)
Someday, I'm going to get writing again, and when I do, this will make me feel better. I'll think, "I'm not pathologically limited in my ability to think past 35K, I'm just hitting the middle bit, that's all." And then I'll find something to break, and hopefully that will help no end. Someday. :P :)
...Good thing I'm not the professional, innit?
Shhh!
Lady, I've watched your progress reports. I don't think so.
The secret to writing is deciding that all you have to do is finish. There's a reason we don't let writers decide whether they're any good or not.
*swoon*
You're good at this, you know that?
I'm going to start throwing a few more complications at my characters and see if anything feels right...