it's a great life, if you don't weaken (matociquala) wrote,
it's a great life, if you don't weaken
matociquala

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Soooo much better than it had to be.



I expected to hate it.

But.

*Very* nice. Okay, I laughed my ass off because Orlando Bloom has Kit Marlowe's ratty little moustache. And Johnny Depp is wonderful as the swishiest pirate in the Carribean, with Geoffrey Rush underplaying his villain in lovely counterpoint.

The chick wasn't bad either. *g* (Totally unfair, but I kept getting distracted by dark-haired men in pirate shirts. It's a weakness.)

But what really impressed me was the structural soundness of the movie in general. Everything that plays out is set up; everything that's established is used. Usually in small ways, sometimes in grand ones. Except for the very, very end of the denouement, which I felt hit a false note and contradicted the natural ending of the movie.

I suspect they changed what they intended for test audiences.

This is why you should not always give your readers what they want, but rather what they need.

Which reliance on careful structure meant I knew more or less everything that was going to happen, but, to quote Connie Willis-- "...so I learned how to do it, and thereby rendered myself incapable of every being surprised again."

Also, the comic relief characters didn't annoy me. I have absolutely zero tolerance for comic relief characters. This was clever enough, well-peopled enough with strong characters, plotty enough, and rich enough with smart crosses and double crosses to keep me entertained through the whole damned two hours twenty, or however long it is.



It is not great art. But it was a hell of a lot of fun, and mmmm. Swishy Johnny Depp. Not-so-swishy Orlando Bloom.

Life is good.
Subscribe

  • protect this generation from a raging east infection

    The morning after he killed Eugene Shapiro, Andre Deschenes woke early. from Fifi la Galerienne on Vimeo. A short animated film inspired by the…

  • So, just out of curiousity....

    Given the clues in the book, did anybody guess what A.G. stood for, in Undertow? Nobody's asked, so either you all got it, or nobody cared. ;-)…

  • via jimvanpelt...

    January 8, 2008 For Immediate Release 2007 Philip K. Dick Award Nominees Announced The judges of the 2007 Philip K. Dick Award and the…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 3 comments