it's a great life, if you don't weaken (matociquala) wrote,
it's a great life, if you don't weaken
matociquala

  • Mood:
  • Music:

i'd pay extra for a home-made guarantee

Book report #36: Naomi Novik, Black Powder War

I have mixed emotions about this one. There's an awful lot of travelogue here, which takes some determination to get through, and I can't help but feel that the book falls prey to some of the common flaws of homage--which is to say, mimicking too closely the less-effective bits of the source material. (This is also a problem I had with The Jennifer Morgue, which I otherwise liked a great deal.) In particular, the desert sequence is on the predictable side: we all knew there was going to be a dry oasis, and a sandstorm, and then when we got to the mountains there would inevitably be an avalanche, because we have all read this book before.

It does pick up once the political intrigue starts, although I more and more want to bite Laurence as the series progresses. He's both a little too perfect and a little too stupidly honorable in ways that force him to engage with plot he has no real reason for encountering otherwise, which is also probably something I should be blaming on the source.

On the neither-good-nor-bad-but-slightly-brainhurty side, I am somewhat distracted by the way in which Laurence related to Temeraire as a somewhat naive but very intelligent wife, even to calling him "my dear" and not wanting to confuse him too much with the exigencies of war. I'm not sure if it's genderfuck, parody, or what, but it results in my endlessly envisioning Temeraire in skirts and an apron, which makes my eyes cross.

There is much adventure towards the end, and hopeless battles, and cleverness, and that is very good. (Even if this all happens in the midst of me wanting to bite Laurence, who somehow seems to have forgotten his sworn duty and his orders, (which he's been rigorously faithful to thus far, even when he thinks they are dumb) in pursuit of the Plot.)

The baaaaaaaaaaaby dragon is awesome. She's going to be trouble for books on end, I'm sure. I'm seriously looking forward to her when she's grown.
Tags: 100 book reports
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 23 comments